Forgetting Sarah Marshall

R Apr 17, 2008 Comedy · Nearly two hours that breezes by thanks to genuine character development between laughs.
Solid crowd-pleaser
7.1/10
IMDb
84%
Fresh
67
67/100
Metacritic
3.3/5
Letterboxd
🎬
6.5/10
TMDB
Rewatch
warm comfort
Attention
half watch ok
Phone-check
medium
Ages
holds up

The brief

Jason Segel's naked vulnerability (literally and figuratively) anchors this surprisingly sweet breakup comedy that never lets its R-rated raunch overshadow genuine heartbreak. The Hawaii setting feels like a real vacation rather than just pretty backdrops, while Russell Brand steals scenes as a hilariously pretentious rock star who's somehow still likable. What could have been another mean-spirited guy comedy instead finds warmth in watching decent people navigate messy relationships without anyone being the villain. Perfect for fans of Knocked Up or Pineapple Express who want their laughs with actual emotional stakes.

heartbreak comedy tropical healing naked vulnerability relationship messy raunchy sweet breakup recovery hawaii vacation

The verdict

If you enjoy raunchy comedies that balance genuine emotion with R-rated humor, this is a surprisingly heartfelt breakup story that earns both its laughs and tears. If you prefer cleaner comedies or get uncomfortable with full-frontal male nudity and crude sexual humor, the raunch will likely overshadow the sweet relationship dynamics.

Watch with

  • 👥 Perfect for friends going through breakups
  • 👫 Great date night for established couples
  • ⚠️ Skip with kids due to nudity and language

Heads up

  • Full frontal male nudity (multiple scenes) (moderate)
  • Strong sexual content and crude humor (frequent)
  • Drug use including marijuana (moderate)

Credits

Director
Nicholas Stoller
Cast
Jason Segel, Kristen Bell, Mila Kunis, Russell Brand, Bill Hader, Jonah Hill, Liz Cackowski
Official synopsis

When actress Sarah Marshall dumps aspiring musician Peter Bretter for rock star Aldous Snow, Peter's world

The Double

Make a night of it
Poster for The Devil Wears Prada 2

Pair this with The Devil Wears Prada 2 (2026)

Both explore professional heartbreak and personal growth through workplace romance complications.

Total runtime: 1h 51m + 2h 0m = 3h 51m

If you liked this