Now You See Me: Now You Don''t

PG-13 Nov 12, 2025 Thriller · Nearly two hours that races by despite convoluted plotting.
Mediocre sequel disappointment
5.9/10
IMDb
50
50/100
Metacritic
2.95/5
Letterboxd
🎬
6.5/10
TMDB
Before you watch

Third Horsemen film with convoluted heist magic, best to watch original first

Rewatch
diminishing returns
Attention
full focus
Phone-check
medium

The brief

Ruben Fleischer brings his zippy energy to this third Horsemen outing, but the magic tricks feel more mechanical than mystical this time around. Jesse Eisenberg still delivers his rapid-fire quips with precision, while Rosamund Pike camps it up deliciously as the diamond-obsessed villain, but the new cast members get lost in the shuffle of increasingly convoluted heist logistics. The film moves at a breakneck pace that papers over plot holes but never quite recaptures the "how did they do that?" wonder of the original. Perfect for fans who just want more of the same slick nonsense, but newcomers should start with the first film.

slick heist thrills flashy illusion spectacle ensemble comedy convoluted plotting stylish crime caper rapid-fire banter

The verdict

If you're a fan of the franchise who enjoys slick heist entertainment and doesn't mind style over substance, this delivers more of Fleischer's zippy energy and Eisenberg's sharp quips. If you're looking for genuine magic movie wonder or haven't seen the original films, the mechanical tricks and convoluted plot will leave you cold.

Watch with

  • 👥 Friends who love popcorn entertainment
  • ⚠️ Skip if you need logical plots

Heads up

  • Criminal violence and chase sequences (moderate)
  • Money laundering and trafficking themes (implied)

Credits

Director
Ruben Fleischer
Cast
Jesse Eisenberg, Dominic Sessa, Ariana Greenblatt, Justice Smith, Rosamund Pike, Woody Harrelson, Dave Franco
Official synopsis

The original Four Horsemen reunite with a new generation of illusionists to take on powerful diamond heiress

The Double

Make a night of it
Poster for Point Break

Pair this with Point Break (1991)

Both feature elaborate heists mixing crime thrills with stylish team dynamics.

Total runtime: 1h 53m + 2h 2m = 3h 55m

If you liked this