Sinners

R Apr 16, 2025 Horror · At 138 minutes, Coogler uses every moment to build suffocating dread rather than rushing to scares.
Critic darling
7.5/10
IMDb
97%
Fresh
84
84/100
Metacritic
4.09/5
Letterboxd
🎬
7.5/10
TMDB
Rewatch
diminishing returns
Attention
full focus
Phone-check
low

The brief

Ryan Coogler takes his partnership with Michael B. Jordan into genuinely unsettling territory, crafting a slow-burn horror that builds dread through suffocating small-town atmosphere rather than cheap scares. Jordan pulls double duty as twin brothers with surprising skill, while the 138-minute runtime lets Coogler marinate in that creeping sense that something is fundamentally wrong beneath the surface. The film feels like early Ari Aster meets Jordan Peele's social commentary, trading jump scares for psychological unease that lingers long after the credits. Perfect for horror fans who prefer their terror earned through character work and mounting tension rather than gore and gotcha moments.

psychological dread small-town gothic slow-burn terror family trauma atmospheric horror southern gothic twin mythology

The verdict

If you crave psychological horror that builds terror through atmosphere and character work rather than jump scares, this is an exceptional slow-burn thriller that showcases both Coogler's directorial prowess and Jordan's range. If you prefer fast-paced horror with immediate payoffs or get restless during lengthy character studies, the deliberate pacing and 138-minute runtime will test your patience.

Watch with

  • 👥 Horror fans who appreciate character-driven scares
  • 👫 Date night for couples who love discussing themes
  • ⚠️ Skip if you prefer fast-paced horror

Heads up

  • Psychological horror with disturbing imagery (moderate)
  • Family trauma and violence themes (moderate)
  • Some intense supernatural sequences (moderate)

Credits

Director
Ryan Coogler
Cast
Michael B. Jordan, Hailee Steinfeld, Miles Caton, Jack O'Connell, Wunmi Mosaku, Jayme Lawson, Omar Benson Miller
Official synopsis

Trying to leave their troubled lives behind, twin brothers return to their hometown to start again, only to

The Double

Make a night of it
Poster for You Were Never Really Here

Pair this with You Were Never Really Here (2017)

Both explore damaged men returning home to face buried trauma.

Total runtime: 2h 18m + 1h 29m = 3h 47m

If you liked this